Fly picker
What fly should I use?
Answer three questions about the water in front of you. The honest short answer, before you do: if nothing is rising, fish a nymph. Trout take most of their food under the surface, so an empty-looking river usually means the food is somewhere you cannot see it, not that the fish have stopped eating.
Every fly below comes from our 55-card library, with what it imitates and how it is fished. Nothing here is sponsored and nothing is for sale on this page.
Three questions
Answer what you know. The list below narrows as you go, and every fly in it links through to what it imitates and how to fish it.
-
Rainbow Warrior
Midge and small mayfly pupae, with heavy flash
-
Muddler Minnow
Sculpins, baitfish, grasshoppers and stoneflies
-
Woolly Bugger
Leeches, baitfish, large nymphs and crayfish — anything alive and swimming
-
Soft Hackle
Emerging caddis and mayflies
-
Caddis Pupa
Caddisflies in the pupal stage, rising to hatch
-
RS2
Emerging mayflies, especially baetis, trapped in the film
-
WD-40
Emerging midges and small baetis mayflies
-
Serendipity
Midge and caddis larvae, and emerging pupae
-
Snow Cone Midge
Chironomid pupae hanging in the water column
-
Disco Midge
Midge larvae and pupae, with deliberate flash
-
Zebra Midge
Midge pupae
-
Green Weenie
Inchworms and caddis larvae
-
Lightning Bug
Small mayfly nymphs, with heavy attractor flash
-
Clouser Minnow
Baitfish and minnows
-
Duracell Nymph
Mayfly nymphs, with a UV-active attractor sheen
-
Blowtorch
Mayfly and small stonefly nymphs, with a hot collar
-
Frenchie
Mayfly nymphs with a bright hot spot
-
Perdigon
Mayfly nymphs, fished as a fast-sinking competition pattern
-
Hare's Ear Nymph
Mayfly nymphs, caddis pupae and scuds — deliberately ambiguous
-
Pheasant Tail Nymph
Mayfly nymphs, especially baetis
-
Prince Nymph
Stonefly and mayfly nymphs, with attractor flash
-
Copper John
Mayfly and stonefly nymphs, with an attractor's flash
-
Pat's Rubber Legs
Stonefly nymphs
-
Balanced Leech
Leeches suspended horizontally in the water column
-
Deer Hair Mouse
Mice and voles swimming across the surface at night
-
Parachute Adams
Mayfly duns and emergers sitting in the surface film
-
Salmonfly
Adult giant stoneflies of the genus Pteronarcys
-
Yellow Sally
Adult little yellow stoneflies
-
Grasshopper
Adult grasshoppers
-
Ant
Winged ants during a mating flight
-
Beetle
Terrestrial beetles
-
March Brown
Drowned and emerging March Brown mayflies
-
Pale Morning Dun
Ephemerella mayfly duns
-
Blue Wing Olive
Baetis mayfly duns
-
Rusty Spinner
Spent mayfly spinners lying flat on the surface
-
Split Case PMD
Pale Morning Duns caught in the act of emerging
-
Barr's Emerger
Mayfly nymphs and emergers in the film and just below
-
Blue Wing Olive Emerger
Baetis mayflies emerging in and just under the film
-
Green Drake
Large green drake mayflies
-
Scud
Freshwater scuds and shrimp
-
Elk Hair Caddis
Adult caddisflies
-
Royal Wulff
Nothing in particular — a high-visibility attractor
-
Stimulator
Adult stoneflies, large caddis and hoppers
-
Humpy
Nothing specific — a buoyant rough-water attractor
-
Madam X
Hoppers, adult stoneflies and large terrestrials
-
Chubby Chernobyl
Large stoneflies, hoppers and big terrestrials
-
Purple Haze
Mayfly duns, with an attractor's color shift
-
Griffith's Gnat
Clusters of mating midges
-
Trico
Tiny Tricorythodes mayflies, dun and spinner
-
Royal Coachman
Nothing in nature — the original American attractor
-
Pink Albert
Epeorus albertae mayfly duns
-
Adams
Adult mayflies and midges, generically
-
Egg
Loose fish eggs drifting downstream from a spawning bed
-
San Juan Worm
Aquatic worms
-
Bass Popper
Injured baitfish, frogs and large insects struggling on the surface
If you can see what is hatching
This picker works from the situation rather than the insect, because most of the time you cannot identify what is in the air and you still have to tie something on. When you can identify it, start there instead — the hatch guide covers the eighteen that matter and lists the flies that match each one, month by month.
If you know the river but not the season, the state guides cover what is hatching where, and when.
Questions people ask before they tie one on
What fly should I use if nothing is hatching?
A nymph, nearly always. Trout take the overwhelming majority of their food under the surface, so "nothing is happening" usually means "nothing is happening where I can see it". A weighted nymph fished dead drift through the deeper water covers the situation more often than any dry fly will.
How do I know which size fly to use?
Match the size of what you can see before you worry about the pattern. A fly that is roughly the right size and roughly the right colour will out-fish an exact imitation two sizes too big. Every fly in the library below lists the sizes it is tied in.
What is the one fly to use if I can only pick one?
A Parachute Adams in the middle sizes comes closest. It is close enough to a great many mayflies to pass, it floats well enough to see, and it has caught fish on more rivers than any other dry fly. That is not the same as saying it is the best fly on any particular day.
Should I fish a dry fly or a nymph?
Fish a dry fly when you can see fish taking things off the surface, and a nymph the rest of the time. The temptation is the other way round, because a dry fly is more fun to watch. Covering water with a nymph when nothing is rising catches more fish than waiting for a hatch that may not come.