Counted, not guessed
Best flies for trout
12 patterns, ranked by how often they appear across our 50 state guides and 18 hatch pages. The top three — Elk Hair Caddis, Woolly Bugger, Blue Wing Olive — cover fish feeding on top, fish feeding underneath, and fish that need provoking, which is most of trout fishing in three flies.
How this list was made
Every other ranking of trout flies is somebody's opinion. This one is a count. We wrote 50 state guides and 18 hatch pages, each researched separately, and every one names the flies that work there. This page adds up how often each pattern appears in both. The numbers are printed next to every fly so you can see the working.
What the number is not: it measures how often a fly is recommended across those sources, not how many fish it has caught. Nobody has that data, including the people who write lists as though they do. A shop within sight of the water you are fishing knows more than any national ranking, this one included.
The 12
-
Number 1: Elk Hair Caddis
30 of 50 state guides 3 of 18 hatches Dry Fly · #12-#18
Adult caddisflies
Late spring through autumn, strongest in evening when caddis are egg-laying. A reliable searching fly on freestone water any time between hatches.
-
Number 2: Woolly Bugger
25 of 50 state guides 3 of 18 hatches Streamer · #4-#10
Leeches, baitfish, large nymphs and crayfish — anything alive and swimming
Every month, every water type. Particularly good in high or colored water, at dawn and dusk, and when nothing is hatching.
-
Number 3: Blue Wing Olive
25 of 50 state guides 1 of 18 hatches Dry Fly · #16-#20
Baetis mayfly duns
Spring and autumn, and through winter on tailwaters. Best on overcast, cold, drizzling days — the worse the weather feels, the better the hatch.
-
Number 4: Hare's Ear Nymph
18 of 50 state guides 4 of 18 hatches Nymph · #12-#18
Mayfly nymphs, caddis pupae and scuds — deliberately ambiguous
Year round. Particularly good in spring and during caddis emergences, and as a searching nymph on water you do not know.
-
Number 5: Zebra Midge
17 of 50 state guides 3 of 18 hatches Midge · #18-#22
Midge pupae
All year, and essential in winter. Tailwaters in particular fish midges almost every day of the season.
-
Number 6: San Juan Worm
16 of 50 state guides 3 of 18 hatches Worm Pattern · #10-#14
Aquatic worms
Year round, and at its very best in high, colored or rising water after rain or a flow change.
-
Number 7: Clouser Minnow
16 of 50 state guides 1 of 18 hatches Streamer · #2-#6
Baitfish and minnows
Spring through autumn wherever fish are eating baitfish. Prime time is any period of low light or high aggression.
-
Number 8: Pheasant Tail Nymph
12 of 50 state guides 4 of 18 hatches Nymph · #14-#20
Mayfly nymphs, especially baetis
Every month of the year. Strongest before and during mayfly hatches, when nymphs are active and moving toward the surface.
-
Number 9: Parachute Adams
9 of 50 state guides 7 of 18 hatches Dry Fly · #12-#18
Mayfly duns and emergers sitting in the surface film
Any mayfly hatch, and particularly on flat or slow water where a high-riding fly gets refused. Excellent in the last hour of light when you cannot see a dark fly.
-
Number 10: Scud
11 of 50 state guides 2 of 18 hatches Nymph/Wet Fly · #12-#18
Freshwater scuds and shrimp
Year round on tailwaters and spring creeks. Especially good in winter, and immediately after a change in flow when scuds get dislodged.
-
Number 11: Egg
10 of 50 state guides 2 of 18 hatches Egg Imitation · #10-#14
Loose fish eggs drifting downstream from a spawning bed
Autumn through spring, during and immediately after salmon and trout spawning runs.
-
Number 12: Griffith's Gnat
9 of 50 state guides 3 of 18 hatches Dry Fly · #18-#24
Clusters of mating midges
Winter above all, when midges are the only thing hatching. Also excellent on calm mornings and evenings year-round, and on tailwaters any time.
If you are buying five
In order: Elk Hair Caddis, Woolly Bugger, Blue Wing Olive, Hare's Ear Nymph, Zebra Midge. Two or three sizes of each beats one size of twice as many — size is what fish refuse over before they refuse a pattern.
For how many to carry, how to organise them and what to do at the bin, read what flies a beginner actually needs — that answers the how-many question this page deliberately leaves alone. If you already have flies and want to know which to tie on today, the three-question picker narrows it by conditions.
Questions about trout flies
What is the best all-round trout fly?
By this count it is the Elk Hair Caddis, which 30 of our 50 state guides name. That is a statement about how widely a pattern is recommended, not a promise about your river on Saturday. Local knowledge beats any national list, and a fly shop within sight of the water beats both.
How many trout flies do I really need?
About a dozen patterns, in two or three sizes each, covers nearly everything a trout angler meets in a season. More sizes of fewer flies beats more flies in one size, because size is what fish refuse over first.
Is one fly enough to start with?
No, but three is close. A dry fly you can see, a weighted nymph, and something that moves — the first three on this list happen to be exactly that, which is less of a coincidence than it looks. Those three cover fish feeding on top, fish feeding underneath, and fish that need provoking.
Does the exact pattern matter?
Less than size, and much less than drift. A roughly right fly presented well out-fishes an exact imitation dragged across the current. That is the reason this list is twelve patterns rather than a hundred.